In 2006, Amanda left NYCB to be an original cast member in Phantom: The Las Vegas Spectacular, under the direction of Hal Prince and Gillian Lynne. She returned to New York the following year, and from 2007-2009, she worked in Phantom on Broadway and on the National Tour. In 2010, Amanda was selected as the "swing" in the original Broadway cast of Twyla Tharp's Come Fly Away. When the show moved to the Encore Theatre in Las Vegas, Ms. Tharp invited her to be the dance captain for the production. In 2011, Amanda graduated summa cum laude from Fordham University with a B.A. in Arts Administration, and rejoined Broadway's Phantom of the Opera, serving as the show's assistant dance captain until 2014. From 2015-2018, Amanda was on faculty at Central Pennsylvania Youth Ballet, and she choreographed for their students and the students of Ballet Academy East in New York City.
Currently, Amanda teaches company class at New York City Ballet, serves on faculty at Kanyok Arts Initiative, and is a fitness instructor at Pure Barre, Upper West Side.